Search www.satyamag.com

Satya has ceased publication. This website is maintained for informational purposes only.

To learn more about the upcoming Special Edition of Satya and Call for Submissions, click here.

back issues

 

February 2000
World Bank Versus World Health

By Neal D. Barnard

 

The World Bank has proved again that the pen is indeed mightier than the sword. The sword—a scythe harvesting the traditional grains that have kept China free of the heart disease and cancer epidemics plaguing Western nations—was defeated December 22 1999 by a stroke of the World Bank’s pen, which signed a $93.5 million check to build 130 feedlots and five processing centers for China’s nascent beef industry.

The World Health Organization would have had it differently. Its figures show that the traditional Chinese diet, rich in nutrients from rice and vegetables, with little meat and virtually no dairy products, has kept Western diseases at arm’s length. An improved food distribution network has eliminated the shortages that have plagued some other Asian countries. Per-capita food intake is actually higher than in the U.S.

Unfortunately, Western eating habits had already gained a foothold in some parts of China without support from the World Bank. Health researchers from Cornell and Oxford universities, along with the Chinese government, lamented how fast food, steak, and cheese were starting to replace traditional rice and noodle dishes. Those Chinese counties with the most aggressive Westernization of their diets are showing the highest rates of western-style medical problems.

Ironically, it is just as America is recognizing the need to “Easternize” its own diet, with rice, soy products, and more and more vegetarian and vegan options, that World Bank bureaucrats decided to promote a Westernization of China’s diet. Instead of supporting the use of grain as a cholesterol-free dietary staple for humans, the myopic enterprise will feed grain to cattle to produce meat loaded with fat and cholesterol. From Bank headquarters in Northwest Washington, they will never see the myocardial infarctions in Beijing, hypertension in Shanghai, or diabetes in Chungking caused by these eating habits.

It is a model, not just of poor health, but of incredible inefficiency. Kilo after kilo of grain proteins fed to cattle yield only one-tenth of their amount of protein as meat—exactly the kind of fiasco Frances Moore Lappé described in Diet for a Small Planet in 1971, as President Nixon prepared to visit China. With a burgeoning world population, she wrote, it is grain and vegetables that will sustain us, and a meat-based diet that will steal these simple foods to fatten cattle.

In building a network of feedlots, one has to wonder if the World Bankers even bothered to consider what feedlot runoff does to rivers and streams in the U.S. Of course, the World Bank’s efforts to help China make a killing in cattle farming is aimed not at good health or a clean environment, but at economic investment. No doubt, it will pay off for some cattle ranchers in China, who will edge out vegetable and rice acreage. And, almost as if they planned it that way, there will be a bright future in China’s medical industries. In the decades ahead, as heart attacks become the order of the day, the World Bank can invest in the Chinese pharmaceutical industry. It, of course, will have to do battle with surgical suppliers, to see if the prescription-writing pen is mightier than the coronary bypass scalpel. The power of a healthful plant-based diet will have long since been forgotten.

Neal D. Barnard, M.D., is the founder of the Physicians Committee for Responsible Medicine, and has written five diet-related books, including Eat Right, Live Longer and Foods That Fight Pain. For information, contact www.pcrm.org.

This article reprinted with the kind permission of PCRM. A shorter version of this article appeared in the New York Times (12/24/99).


 


© STEALTH TECHNOLOGIES INC.
All contents are copyrighted. Click here to learn about reprinting text or images that appear on this site.