Satya has ceased publication. This website is maintained for informational purposes only.

To learn more about the upcoming Special Edition of Satya and Call for Submissions, click here.

back issues


June/July 2003
Vegetarian Advocate: Meat Equals Misery
By Jack Rosenberger



It is impossible to ignore the human misery, pain and turmoil caused by the habit of eating animal flesh—unless, of course, you like to eat animal flesh. Take, for instance, the current epidemic of severe acute respiratory syndrome, known as SARS, which is wreaking havoc upon areas of Asia and North America. The SARS virus surfaced late last year in Hong Kong and the neighboring province of Guangdong in southern China, then rapidly spread to Canada, Taiwan, Vietnam, and large sections of central and northern China. So far, the SARS epidemic has cost China and the world economy tens of billions of dollars. For millions of people around the world, daily life has been turned upside down as the fear of being contaminated with the deadly SARS virus is a distinct possibility.

At press time, SARS has killed approximately 735 people. More than 8,200 persons are infected, many of whom are being quarantined.

What caused the SARS epidemic? A likely answer to this question is the ingrained habit of eating animal flesh.

From Animals to Humans
In May, the World Health Organization reported that new research suggests that the epicenter of the SARS epidemic is the live animal markets of Guangdong Province. Here, workers handle and butcher innumerable species of animals—including badgers, cats, chickens, frogs, snakes, turtles, and a weasel-like animal called the masked palm civet—for the pleasure of their customers. An unusually high percentage of the first SARS victims in Guangdong were butchers and other food handlers at the live animal markets, and scientists believe that during the rearing, slaughter and preparation of animals, the virus may have jumped from animals to humans.

Researchers have found a virus nearly identical to the one that causes SARS in humans in three animal species commonly butchered in the Guangdong animal markets, considered by some as delicacies. The SARS-like virus has been found in six masked palm civets, a raccoon dog, and a badger.

A threatened species, the masked palm civet is commonly eaten in the fall and winter in China. The custom stems from the popular belief that it helps one’s body combat the cold weather.

In the Vegetarian Advocate column of May 2002 titled “Did Carnivores Cause AIDS?”, I discussed the mounting evidence suggesting that AIDS started in Western and Central Africa and seems to have made the leap from animals to humans when hunters slaughtered chimps for “bush meat.” Apparently HIV, the virus believed to cause AIDS, infected human beings through bites and blood exposure when hunting or butchering chimpanzees.

Unlike SARS, the AIDS epidemic has had two decades to work its way around the planet. The human toll? Grandparents, teenagers, mothers and fathers, mere babies. To date, an estimated 20 to 25 million people have died from AIDS, killing roughly one person every ten seconds. Future victims? An estimated 14,000 people become infected with the AIDS virus each day. Currently, at least 40 million are reportedly infected with HIV.

Compared to AIDS, the fact that Mad Cow disease or Bovine Spongiform Encephalopathy—another health epidemic caused by carnivores and the apparent cause of Creutzfeldt-Jacob disease (CJD) in humans—has just surfaced in cattle in Canada for the first time, causing many countries to ban the importation of Canadian beef and causing unrest and uncertainty in the world’s financial markets, seems utterly trivial.

Good for What?
One of the truly diabolical ironies about carnivorism is that, despite all of the compelling medical evidence, people eat animal flesh because they believe it’s good for their health. Yet, a meat-based diet is responsible for the ill health and premature death of countless millions of people each year. In the developed world, most of the leading causes of death, such as heart disease and numerous cancers, are caused in part by excessive meat consumption.

However, it’s difficult to know what’s growing faster—the medical evidence that eating meat is dangerous for one’s health or the amount of meat that people consume on a daily basis.

During the last several years, medical researchers have explored the connection between diet and Alzheimer’s disease. For years, researchers have noted that people with Alzheimer’s tend to have high levels of an amino acid called homocysteine. A recent study by researchers at Boston University and Tufts University suggests a connection between high homocysteine levels in healthy people and their later development of Alzheimer’s. What causes a person’s levels of homocysteine to increase? Yes, a diet that is heavy in animal protein and light in fruit and leafy green vegetables. Unlike meat, fruit and vegetables lower one’s homocysteine level.

Moreover, several studies presented at last year’s international conference on Alzheimer’s disease, held in Stockholm, suggest that the risk factors for heart disease—such as high blood pressure, excess weight and high cholesterol—may contribute to Alzheimer’s. Likewise, a Columbia University study found that a “diet high in calories and fat may increase the risk of Alzheimer’s disease in people who are genetically susceptible to the mind-robbing disorder,” reports the Associated Press. “The study found that people who consumed the most calories and fat faced double the risk of developing Alzheimer’s.”

On top of this are cases of CJD that were found in autopsies of people diagnosed with Alzheimer’s in studies by researchers at Yale University and the University of Pittsburgh. Symptoms of these two diseases are similar: dissolution into a debilitating dementia.

With such a growing body of evidence suggesting that meat-eating is so risky, why would anyone choose to be a lifelong carnivore?

All contents are copyrighted. Click here to learn about reprinting text or images that appear on this site.